Chris Chutnik, owner of Blue Cafe in Basking Ridge, said "Sir Paul McCartney" stopped in on Friday, Dec. 16.
"I grew up on his music," Chutnik said. "It was an amazing experience to shake his hand and talk to the legend. Super nice man."
Shevell is a New Jersey native, having grown up in Edison.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Jersey City and receive free news updates.